Family Meals Focus
The Ellyn Satter Institute Newsletter
Stop being hysterical about “obesity”
by Ellyn Satter, Registered Dietitian and Family Therapist
Chasing weight loss does more harm than good. Instead, devote yourself to weight-neutral wellness: Become eating competent, move in enjoyable ways, and respect your body.
Overweight definitions are spurious
Examination of recent obesity data makes it clear that it is time to stop chasing weight loss! This is not to say that we should or will let ourselves go. Instead, we can address the issue in a way that it can be solved. We can responsibly devote ourselves to weight-neutral approaches to good health (Health at Every Size, if you will): Eating well (in my definition, that would be the Satter Eating Competence Model), moving in ways that we enjoy and are therefore sustainable, and developing respect for bodies.
The incidence of overweight in adults and children has leveled off, probably not because obesity interventions work – they don’t. Although hope springs eternal in the folks who throw millions annually at fruitless weight-loss efforts, in our saner moments we know there is no cure. The leveling-off is more likely because we have achieved some sort of equilibrium with recent years’ changes in family meal patterns and the marketplace, with the dietary confusion and disorder from the extreme food selection rules that got a toe-hold in the 1980s, and, yes, with attempts at weight loss. These attempts show a pattern of beginning each weight loss effort weighing more than at the start of the previous one.1
Health policy contributes to weight-loss pressure by calling us obese when we are above average weight and telling us that our weight is killing us when it is doing nothing of the sort. The American Medical Association officially designates obesity as a disease. In reality, the cure is worse than the disease: Lifelong misery about eating and weight, repeated, medically damaging, and costly failed weight-loss attempts, shame, and self-loathing.2
Adult and child obesity incidence has leveled off
Not pursuing weight loss doesn’t mean we will let ourselves go. Instead, we will address weight issues in the way they can be solved.
Based on 2013-2014 National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) data, the 2013-2014 incidence of child and adult obesity remains unchanged since 2011-2012:
- Adult obesity (BMI ≥30): 35% for men, 40% for women. Slight increases for women since 2011-2012.3
- Adult class 3 obesity (BM≥40):6% for men, 10% for women. Slight increases for women since 2011-2012.3
- Child and adolescent obesity (BMI ≥ 95th percentile): No change since 2011-2012 in values adjusted for sex, age, race/Hispanic origin, and education level of the household head.4
- Child and adolescent extreme obesity (BMI ≥ 120% of the 95th percentile): No change in adjusted values since 2011-2012.4
Obese? Or just above normal?
Generally, biological data are designated as crossing the line from normal to abnormal at 2 or even 3 standard deviations (SD) away from the mean. Body weight is different. Policy-makers set the line from normal to abnormal for body weight for children at less than 2 SD above the mean, and for adults at the mean!3 No wonder so many of us are “overweight!” Rather than being a disease, as defined by the American Medical Association, high BMI defined by the policy-makers appears to be a variant of normal. This is particularly true for adults, where the diagnostic cutoffs are at the mean. Not only that, but whether or not we consider obesity cutoffs to be reasonable, compared with children, adults are defined as being obese at lower percentiles. That means a person can leave childhood at “normal” weight and enter adulthood obese!
- Child overweight: BMI plots at the 85th percentile or above, which is 1 standard deviation (SD) above the mean.
- Child obesity: BMI plots at the 95th percentile or above, 1.8 SD above the mean.
- Adult overweight: BMI 24.9-30.0.3 This plots just above the 50th percentile, far less than 1 SD above the mean.3
- “Normal” weight is BMI 18 to 24.9 – at the 50th percentile and below.
- Adult class 3 obesity: BMI 40.3 This plots at ~ the 99th percentile, about 2 SD above the mean.
Is overweight making us sick? Probably not.
The folks calling the shots in today’s health care and policy-making world insist that obesity makes us sick and it is driving up health care costs. The loyal opposition (that would be me and other moderates) say it isn’t so simple. The “cure,” weight reduction dieting and yo-yo weight patterns, are worse than the disease. The shot-callers and the moderates could argue about this for hours – days – with each camp pulling out reams of studies (and opinions) that support our opposite points of view. Obesity correlates to a moderate extent with metabolic syndrome: elevated blood pressure, triglycerides, fasting plasma glucose, insulin resistance, and C-reactive protein and low high-density lipoprotein cholesterol. However, careful studies show that weight loss does not improve those values, and weight loss and regain makes them even worse. Which came first: the metabolic syndrome or the obesity? Does obesity cause metabolic syndrome or vice-versa? Does low weight protect against metabolic syndrome? Maybe, but “normal-weight” people have metabolic syndrome. We know that obesity is a genetic condition – is metabolic syndrome part of the genetically determined mechanism that predisposes to obesity? Whether obesity or metabolic syndrome came first, the correlations at not that high:
- Even at “normal” weight, one-third of women and one-fifth of men have metabolic syndrome compared with 50% of “overweight” (BMI 25.0-29.9) men and 43% of “overweight” women.5
- Two-thirds of “obese” (BMI 30-35) subjects scored within normal ranges for metabolic syndrome, with the other third showing modestly elevated values.6
Obesity doesn’t kill us
- Mortality for adults is lowest when BMI is between 25 and 35.7 You did not misread that: Mortality is lowest at a level defined by health policy as obesity: BMI 25 or 30 and above.
- Mortality goes up in the over-35 BMI category, when that category is lumped together with over-40 BMI – class 3 obesity.7
- Separating the 35-40 BMIs from the over-40 BMIs shows modest risk increase in the 35-40 BMIs and the higher risk in the over-40 BMIs.8 Even the BMI 45 relative risk is still only half that for smoking.
- Obesity mortality is a U-shaped curve, with the low point being BMI 25 to 35. Mortality goes up in the under-25 category, with BMI categories BMI 18 and BMI 40 showiing the same relative risk.8
Seek health in other ways besides weight loss
You can take good care of yourself – sustainably – without tormenting yourself about weight loss. People who are eating competent are healthier in ways that folks cannot achieve and maintain on weight loss regimens: They have better diets, better medical and lab tests, are more active, sleep better, feel better about themselves, and do better socially and emotionally.9 In the same manner, physical fitness does more for your health than getting thin: it is better to be fit and fat than “normal” weight and unfit.10 Weight-neutral interventions such as becoming eating competent11 improve health indicators including self-esteem and body image.12
- Wadden TA, Bartlett S, Letizia KA, Foster GD, Stunkard AJ, Conill A. Relationship of dieting history to resting metabolic rate, body composition, eating behavior, and subsequent weight loss. Am J Clin Nutr. 1992;56:203S-208S.
- Foreyt JP, Brunner RL, Goodrick GK, Cutter G, Brownell KD, St. Jeor ST. Psychological correlates of weight fluctuation. International Journal of Eating Disorders. 1995;17(3):263-275.
- Flegal KM, Kruszon-Moran D, Carroll MD, Fryar CD, Ogden CL. Trends in Obesity Among Adults in the United States, 2005 to 2014. JAMA. 2016;315(21):2284-2291.
- Ogden CL, Carroll MD, Lawman HG, et al. Trends in Obesity Prevalence Among Children and Adolescents in the United States, 1988-1994 Through 2013-2014. JAMA. 2016;315(21):2292-2299.
- Wildman RP, Muntner P, Reynolds K, et al. The obese without cardiometabolic risk factor clustering and the normal weight with cardiometabolic risk factor clustering: prevalence and correlates of 2 phenotypes among the US population (NHANES 1999-2004). Arch Intern Med. 2008;168(15):1617-1624.
- McLaughlin T, Abbasi F, Lamendola C, Reaven G. Heterogeneity in the prevalence of risk factors for cardiovascular disease and type 2 diabetes mellitus in obese individuals: effect of differences in insulin sensitivity. Arch Intern Med. 2007;167:642-648.
- Flegal KM, Kit BK, Orpana H, Graubard BI. Association of all-cause mortality with overweight and obesity using standard body mass index categories: a systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA. 2013;309(1):71-82.
- Aune D, Sen A, Prasad M, et al. BMI and all cause mortality: systematic review and non-linear dose-response meta-analysis of 230 cohort studies with 3.74 million deaths among 30.3 million participants. BMJ. 2016;353:i2156.
- Lohse B. ESI webinar: The evidence base for the Satter Eating Competence Model 2015. 2015; http://ellynsatterinstitute.org/webinars/webinar-evidence-base-for-the-satter-eating-competence-model.php#.
- Vaughn WB, Baruth M, Beets MW, Durstine L, Liu JD, Blair SN. Fitness vs. fatness on all-Cause mortality: A meta-analysis. Progress in Cardiovascular Diseases. 2014:382-390.
- Satter EM. Chapter 4, Eat as Much as You Want. Secrets of Feeding a Healthy Family: How to Eat, How to Raise Good Eaters, How to Cook. Madison, WI: Kelcy Press; 2008:27-43.
- Bacon L, Aphramor L. Weight science: evaluating the evidence for a paradigm shift. Nutr J. 2011;10:9.
More about weight-neutral wellness
Address weight issues in the way they can be solved: eat well, move in sustainable ways, and develop respect for our bodies. Read Ellyn Satter’s Secrets of Feeding a Healthy Family and Your Child’s Weight: Helping Without Harming.
Address weight wisely and well
- Children know how much they need to eat
- Eat as much as you want
- The joy of eating: being a competent eater
- Raise a healthy child who is a joy to feed
- Resolve the weight dilemma
- The “overweight” child
Related issues of Family Meals Focus
- Child overweight: are current guidelines helpful? do they do harm?
- Children who are obsessed with food
- Court-ordered placement for child obesity: what can you do to help?
- Dieting and mental health
- Feeding neglected children mandates division of responsibility in feeding
- Helping without harming with child overweight
- Overweight kids are not gluttons
Stay in touch!
- Join Ellyn Satter on Facebook
- Join other professionals on Clinical Facebook
- See the Family Meals Focus index and publication list
- Want a PDF of this article? Subscribe!
- Sign up for the ESI Blog and other monthly alerts!
- Say thanks for this great information by making a donation to ESI!